What Makes America Great: Immigration

I come from a family of immigrants.  My great-great-grandfather immigrated from the Austro-Hungarian Empire in 1909 on the Carpathia (the same ship that would later rescue Titanic survivors).  While my last name is Italian, I also have random quantities of Swedish, Irish, French, and Scottish blood.  I am who I am because of immigration.  America is the country she is because of immigration.

Immigration offers the best from every culture

We live in an age of multiculturalism.  It is the doctrine preached from universities and dictated by lawmakers.  Multiculturalism says that every culture is equal.  It claims that no culture is in any way ‘better’ than another culture.  This thinking says that you cannot criticize another culture.  You also cannot learn anything better from another culture.

Part of America’s success is her original rejection of multiculturalism.  Sometimes we might have been a little too proud of our culture, but we certainly didn’t view all cultures as equal.  Because we realized that different cultures have different strengths, we were proud about our strengths.  We also realized that other cultures can teach us.  We were open to being taught.  Immigration helped to bring different strengths to our shores.  From pizza, to log cabins, to common law, immigration has provided America with good things from many different cultures.

Immigration offers the best to immigrants

When one of my great-grandfathers moved from Italy to Chicago, it may not seem like he made a positive move.  Chicago, then and now, had some negative connotations, at least for new immigrants.  Yet whatever temporary setbacks he experienced, my great-grandfather had left Italy behind.  My family had a new start.  We finally had the opportunity to advance based on hard work.  We aren’t limited by class systems or caste.  Immigration did not ‘give’ us anything, but it did ‘offer’ us opportunity.

Immigration offers the best for America

You cannot have a strong economy without an expanding population.  America’s capitalist system has brilliantly outperformed any other economic system that the world has ever seen – even when it reveals some rather painful flaws.  Much of that performance only happened because immigration provided the ‘fuel’ for the system.

Immigration brings talent to our country, allowing the best and the brightest an opportunity to advance.  The class system is all about keeping people in their place.  America has a different ideal.  We want to give everyone an opportunity, and those who work hardest will advance.  Many of America’s hardest workers – and most brilliant minds – were immigrants.  They offered, and we accepted, their best.


4 thoughts on “What Makes America Great: Immigration”

  1. A very good article, and I share most of your conclusions. I would only add that the immigrants who came here in the 1900s differed greatly from today’s immigrants in that they had virtually no social services network except their families. That made life tough, very tough, but as “necessity is the mother of invention,” their contributions to our Country were much greater than those of today’s immigrants, particularly the illegal ones. This is not the fault of today’s immigrants, but rather the government’s extensive social welfare programs.

    1. Hello Mrs. McVey! So good to hear from you and it was such a joy to meet you the other night! 🙂

      Thank you for sharing these great thoughts – I thoroughly agree with you! I will make sure our columnist who wrote this sees your comment and he may want to reply as well. He’s currently out of town, so it may be a while.

      Thank you again and God bless!


      1. I enjoyed meeting you also. It is such a blessing to meet bright young minds committed to Christ and to freedom.

    2. Hi Mrs. McVey,
      Thanks for your comments. You make some great points! Sadly, multiculturalism has muted the positive impacts of immigration, since it says we can’t learn from other cultures. Also, like you mentioned, the welfare system encourages people to come, not to offer their best, but to receive support. Despite that, I think we can still value the contributions of immigrants as we seek to learn from them and encourage them to offer their best to a true (rather than crony) capitalist system. – Daniel

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s